Talk:Unnamed Dead Man/@comment-107.192.237.244-20180410183538

Frankly one point: The truth is that Light was sent neither to the void nor for reincarnation, Why? Because he becomes a Shinigami. He waits until his body returns to it's doll form in the purgatorial realms (the tower that DP takes place in), and then when his unjudgable soul exits his physical form he is reincarnated as a vassal of death (Shinigami). So in order to judge another judge you must first make two assumptions: First that your judgement of their judgement is not susceptible to the same errors that led to them making the wrong decision, Two, you must deliberate how they are guilty for judging to the best of their ability in the purest intention they could muster. You must also discount the fact that they are falliable and thus can make the incorrect judgement and still think they are correct with no doubt in their mind (Which Light did), and you must state that this is still wrong. So by definition he is unjudgable because: Arbiters make mistakes as we have seen and thus are susceptible to the first assumption, Arbiters believe that their cause is right but still send some people to the void and others for reincarntion and thus "cherrypick" people that match what they look for to be reincarnated whether this is right or wrong is up for debate but they view it as right. So they are exactly the same as Light, who judges that those who have no ill will towards others are good for society and therefore should live, while others die. The sole difference (As you'd say) is that Light killed innocent people because they were threatening him (In self defense), which any Arbiter would do if they met a force that could destroy them (Though they cannot die), so it is not actually a difference. Either way, both have the exact same function, and thus Light becomes truly unjudgable as it would be the same as deciding whether the function of the Arbiters as a whole is right or wrong, which is impossible as it is the same as asking "What is the point of life?" Because we exist to reproduce, and they exist to judge, therefore it is an unanswerable existential question. The moment Light wrote his first name in his deathnote he became unjudgable because his function became that of judge and therefore his actions as such are unjudgable due to his existence now being comprised solely of that purpose. Thus Light, the Arbiters, and the purpose of reproduction are deemed neither right or wrong because to judge any of them right or wrong is to question why they exist, and existence is itself as there is nothing besides existence.